Thursday, 7 March 2013

Presentation to the Electoral Boundaries and Representation Commission


We would like to thank the Commissioners for this opportunity to present our comments on the proposed riding boundaries outlined in their Preliminary Report of January 17, 2013.[1] Given that the members of our Project Team have undertaken our own riding boundary proposal for all 49 ridings in the Province, we understand the many challenges and the painstaking diligence required to put forward such a proposal.

While we appreciate the work undertaken by the Commissioners in preparing the Preliminary Report, we believe that many of the riding boundaries proposed in this report do not achieve the goals for the redistricting process set out in guiding principles stated in the Electoral Boundaries and Representation Act of 2005.

The Commission has done an admirable job of achieving the numerical equality of their proposed ridings, which is a principle set out in Section 12(1) of the Act. However, the following section of the Act also defines the other criteria that must guide the redistricting process. These are:

12(2) A Commission may depart from the principle of voter parity as set out in subsection (1) in order to achieve effective representation of the electorate as guaranteed by section 3 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and based upon the following considerations:

(a) communities of interest;

(b) effective representation of the English and French linguistic communities;

(c) municipal and other administrative boundaries;

(d) the rate of population growth in a region;

(e) effective representation of rural areas;

(f) geographical features, including the following:

(i) the accessibility of a region;

(ii) the size of a region; and

(iii) the shape of a region; and

(g) any other considerations that the Commission considers appropriate.


Although these principles were affirmed in the Preliminary Report, we are concerned that many of these guiding principles have not been given more consideration in the creation of many of the new ridings.

This is most evident in the Capital Area, where the Commission has decided to rely on hybrid urban-rural ridings to meet a quantitative test but trumps the communities of interest, municipal boundaries and the effective representation of rural areas in their proposal.

We understand that you were urged to take this hybrid approach in the previous round of hearings in Fredericton. That should not be construed as popular support for ignoring the Guiding Principles.

Generally, there is an over-use of hybrid urban-rural ridings in the Commission’s proposal. This includes the metropolitan Moncton area as well as Bathurst and Edmundston. In the latter cases, the Preliminary Report divides these formerly unified communities into two hybrid ridings.

As well, many of the proposed rural ridings, such as Gagetown-Petitcodiac or the ridings in the Upper Saint John River Valley, do not adequately reflect historic market and transportation patterns.

The representation of linguistic communities is also an important factor in the success or failure of a redistricting process in New Brunswick. In addition to their large size, the two rural Miramichi ridings combine the Anglophone lumber communities of the interior with the ocean-oriented Francophone communities of the coast.

The relatively small Anglophone community of the Tantramar area has little choice but to be combined with nearby Francophone areas in order to achieve a riding with numerical equality. However, rather than combining it with Memramcook, which has significant cultural and historic significance for Acadians, a more viable choice would be to look northwards for a solution.

As a representative, deliberative body, the Legislative Assembly functions best when Members of the Assembly can effectively represent the ridings from which they are chosen. For this purpose, a riding that reflects a single community of interest is better than a riding that straddles differing, or even conflicting, communities of interest.

While this is not always possible, especially in small province such as ours, it is better to emphasize the commonalities that exist than to deliberately combine conflicting communities of interest in a proposed riding.

The study of public opinion in New Brunswick reveals a number of important factors with regard to our political culture. While New Brunswickers share many views and values, it would be an erroneous over-simplification to assume that New Brunswickers think alike about all things and differences in language, community size and region are non-factors.

In fact, when the views of New Brunswickers on public issues are examined, the differences in between urban and rural New Brunswickers can be strikingly different even though they may live in relative proximity to each other. Likewise, just as members of our two linguistic communities share many of the same views, there are important differences that need to be respected, if not recognized, in the way these communities are represented in the Legislature.

To be an effective deliberative and representative body, the Legislative Assembly needs to be comprised of members who can effectively represent the interests of their constituents. This task should be made more difficult by proposing ridings that ignore existing communities of interest or undermine the needs of both urban and rural residents of New Brunswick to have their voices heard in the Legislature.

Given the many challenges that we are facing as a Province, and the increasing cynicism many New Brunswickers have about their representative institutions, we should not be making a difficult situation worse. The challenge is to create ridings that improve the ability of New Brunswickers to be represented – and to feel represented – rather than a riding structure that encourages feelings of alienation and disenfranchisement.

We cannot cure all the ills of our political culture with a better, more representative set of riding boundaries. It is, however, a positive step in demonstrating that care has been taken to get the basics right. That is the approach we are taking in our proposal. 

As has been noted by the Commissioners, it is easier to identify a problem with a riding, or a set of ridings, than to offer a solution. A change to one riding creates a “domino effect” that alters other ridings. This is especially true when the principle of numerical equality, even with an allowable variance of plus or minus five percent, must be respected.

With this in mind, we are presenting our own proposal for the 49 ridings represented in the Legislative Assembly. In the attached table, we demonstrate that each of these ridings achieves the principle of numerical equality within the five percent variance.

At first glance, you will note that the riding map we propose has two important attributes. The first is how much this map retains some of the geographic boundaries of the current riding map. Given that the existing boundaries already represent established communities of interest, it is not surprising that there is an “echo” of the current map in our proposal.

The second is the level of agreement we have with some of the proposed changes offered in the Preliminary Report, especially with regard to the urban core of the City of Saint John, the Charlotte County ridings, the creation of a Miramichi City riding, and parts of the Acadian Peninsula.

While we do not have the same resources as those available to the Commission, we have constructed a proposal that solves many of the problems that we have already identified with regard to the proposal contained in the Preliminary Report. Further, from the media reporting of some of the earlier sessions, this proposal would also address some of the other issues that have been brought to your attention.

In the process to develop our proposal, we obtained a better understanding of the challenging task that you have undertaken as Commissioners. It is not easy to balance the need to reflect communities of interest and the other important qualitative factors with the principle of numerical equality. However, we believe that we have met this challenge and that the proposal we are offering today better reflects the needs of New Brunswickers for effective representation and the needs of the Legislative Assembly as a deliberative and law-making body.   

We realize that a proposal of this complexity and detail will require further examination and study. We will provide the Commission with as much detail as you need to assess and verify our proposal. Further, we are willing to work with Commission staff, as volunteers, to address any questions they might have and provide additional insight into the decisions that are reflected in this proposal.

Thank you.
 

Proposed Ridings
#
Name
# of Voters
% of EQ
Variance
1
Campbellton - Dalhousie
11,417
101.3%
148
2
Nigadoo-Chaleur
11,692
103.8%
423
3
Nepisiguit - Centre Peninsule
11,239
99.7%
-30
4
Bathurst
11,560
102.6%
291
5
Caraquet
11,255
99.9%
-14
6
Shippagan – Lamèque – Miscou
11,660
103.5%
391
7
Tracadie-Sheila
11,411
101.3%
142
8
Miramichi City
11,725
104.0%
456
9
Upper Miramichi
11,453
101.6%
184
10
Miramichi Bay
10,728
95.2%
-541
11
Kent North
10,824
96.1%
-445
12
Kent South
10,997
97.6%
-272
13
Cocagne - Lakeville
10,826
96.1%
-443
14
Shediac
11,048
98.0%
-221
15
Tantramar - Cap Pele
10,912
96.8%
-357
16
Memramcook – Dieppe
11,235
99.7%
-34
17
Dieppe Centre
11,263
99.9%
-6
18
Moncton East
11,176
99.2%
-93
19
Moncton West
11,162
99.1%
-107
20
Moncton North
10,855
96.3%
-414
21
Moncton Mountain Road
10,875
96.5%
-394
22
Petitcodiac
10,736
95.3%
-533
23
Riverview
11,172
99.1%
-97
24
Albert
11,078
98.3%
-191
25
Kings East
11,081
98.3%
-188
26
Hampton Fundy
11,553
102.5%
284
27
Quispamsis
11,236
99.7%
-33
28
Rothesay
11,460
101.7%
191
29
Saint John East
11,798
104.7%
529
30
Saint John Harbour
11,133
98.8%
-136
31
Saint John Portland
11,501
102.1%
232
32
Saint John Lancaster
11,005
97.7%
-264
33
Grand Bay-Westfield-Kingston Peninsula
10,930
97.0%
-339
34
Charlotte - The Isles
11,179
99.2%
-90
35
Charlotte - Campobello
10,809
95.9%
-460
36
Oromocto - Lincoln
11,744
104.2%
475
37
Grand Lake - Gagetown
11,406
101.2%
137
38
Fredericton - Nashwaaksis
11,368
100.9%
99
39
Fredericton - Fort Nashwaak
11,065
98.2%
-204
40
Fredericton - New Maryland
11,467
101.8%
198
41
Fredericton South
11,439
101.5%
170
42
York
11,728
104.1%
459
43
York North
11,172
99.1%
-97
44
Woodstock
11,628
103.2%
359
45
Carleton
11,671
103.6%
402
46
Grand Falls - Victoria
11,631
103.2%
362
47
Restigouche - St. Leonard
11,628
103.2%
359
48
Madawaska
11,176
99.2%
-93
49
Edmundston - St. Basile
11,244
99.8%
-25

 



[1] This proposal is being submitted on behalf of the NB Riding Proposal Project Team, a volunteer, non-partisan effort by Chris Baker, William Blanchette, Bob Doiron and Brian McCain.

Tuesday, 12 February 2013

The Food Policy Crisis is Here

You can’t eat money. Yet, it seems that more and more money is needed to eat. This is not just an issue for the developing world, or for families on social assistance. The rising cost of food – basic staples such as bread and milk – is becoming an issue for an increasing majority of Canadians and New Brunswickers. It is also an issue that policy makers in our province and in our country have been content, so far, to ignore.
 
Perhaps one of the reasons why decision-makers have been so complacent on this front is due to our agricultural heritage. After all, Canada enjoys a reputation as the bread basket to the world and our food products, grains, meat, dairy, fish and seafood, are in high demand around the world. But there are several reasons why we should not be taking our plentiful, if increasingly expensive, domestic food supply for granted.
 
Canada is a trading nation. In fact, we draw far more of our economic prosperity from international trade than any other G8 nation. And, in this nation of traders, New Brunswick is the most trade dependant of any province – more than Ontario with its auto sector, Alberta with its oil, or British Columbia with its access to the Pacific Rim. New Brunswickers have a vested interest in fair, well-regulated global markets.
 
However, we also need to maintain domestic food security – the ability to feed ourselves based on the food that we produce within our borders. This policy is being challenged by many of our trading partners, who want free access to our domestic markets for their food products. While they have harsh criticism for our “protectionist” policies, such as supply management or food safety regulations, many of these countries, like the United States or the member countries of the European Union, provide lavish subsidies to their agricultural sectors. As much as they like to talk about liberalized trade on food and food products, these countries are not ready to level the playing field.
 
In addition to protecting our domestic market from unfair (or, at least, unequal) trade policies and practices, domestic food security is also an important attribute of our national sovereignty. Just as we need to protect the integrity of our borders and our territory, which we do with our collective security arrangements with NATO, NORAD and the United Nations, we need to ensure the health and well-being of our population. How sovereign is a country that cannot feed itself?
 
Dramatic increases in food prices pose as much danger to social stability and well-being as drought and famine. As much as some like to credit social media for the overthrow of repressive governments in Tunisia, Libya and Egypt, public discontent in those countries – and in many others – has much more to do with the rising cost of basic foods. It wasn’t Facebook that prompted a broad coalition of people to take to the streets and public squares demanding change; it was the price of rice.
 
Neither Canada nor New Brunswick is immune from the upward pressure on the cost of basic foods. Ask anyone who has been doing the family shopping.
The solution is not to open our markets to cheaper food products from other countries. Not only would our domestic food producers be swamped by unfair competition, we would lose control of how the food we eat is produced. We pride ourselves in maintaining high standards for food safety and for animal welfare as part of our food supply. Would we be ready to sacrifice our standards for a cheaper litre of milk?
 
That is the challenge we are facing. We want to maintain our high standards and we want our food prices to be affordable. We want to be able to feed ourselves and to trade our surplus with other countries to get those foods we cannot grow ourselves.
 
Instead of complacency in the agri-food sector, we need action from our policy makers. Frankly, given our history and our capacity, we should be looking to grow more food. Not only would this be a boon for New Brunswick’s rural economy, it would build on our strengths as food processors and exporters. There is an opportunity to be seized.
 
Our supply management system should be part of this solution. As much as we want to hold the line on food prices in our supermarkets, we must ensure that farmers can get a fair price for their products and that processors have a steady supply.
 
Supply management is the best tool that we can use to ensure that consumers, producers and processors benefit from a revitalized agri-food sector. Like any tool, supply management needs to be maintained and improved over time. However, this policy area suffers from the same lassitude among policy-makers that blights the agricultural sector as a whole.
 
The food crisis is already upon us. Rather than acting as helpless bystanders, we need to seize the opportunity that is presented to us.
- 30 -
 
Chris Baker is president of Continuum Research, a Fredericton-based public opinion research firm specializing in public policy and public affairs. His cousins still operate dairy farms in south-western Manitoba.
 
This article was originally published in the February 11, 2013 edition of The Telegraph-Journal.